Titus Livius
59 B.C.E.-17
A.C.E. - Wrote in Latin
The History
of Rome, Vol. IV
Translated by
Rev. Canon Roberts
The History of Rome, Vol. IV
Titus Livius
Editor Ernest Rhys
Translated by Rev. Canon Roberts
Everyman's Library
J.M. Dent and Sons
London
E.P. Dutton and Co.
New York
1912
Published: 1905
Commercial use prohibited.
Livy's History of Rome:
Book 26
The Fate of Capua
26.1
The new consuls, Cn, Fulvius Centimalus and P. Sulpicius Galba,
entered upon office on the 15th of March, and at once convened a
meeting of the senate in the Capitol to discuss questions of State,
the conduct of the war and the distribution of the provinces and
the armies. The retiring consuls-Q. Fulvius and Appius Claudius-retained
their commands and were instructed to prosecute the siege of Capua
unremittingly until they had effected its capture. The recovery
of this city was the main concern of the Romans now. What determined
them was not only the bitter resentment which its defection had
evoked, a feeling which was never more justified in the case of
any city, but also the certainty they felt that, as in its revolt
it had drawn many communities with it, owing to its greatness and
strength, so its recapture would create amongst these communities
a feeling of respect for the power whose sovereignty they had formerly
acknowledged. The praetors of the past year, M. Junius in Etruria
and P. Sempronius in Gaul, had their commands extended and were
each to retain the two legions they had. M. Marcellus was to act
as proconsul and finish the war in Sicily with the army which he
had. If he needed reinforcements he was to take them from the troops
which P. Cornelius was commanding in Sicily, but none were to be
selected from those who had been forbidden by the senate to take
a furlough or return home before the end of the war. The province
of Sicily was assigned to C. Sulpicius, and he was to take over
the two legions which were with P. Cornelius; any reinforcements
he needed were to be supplied from the army of Cn. Fulvius which
had been so disgracefully routed and cut up the previous year in
Apulia. The soldiers who had so disgraced themselves were placed
under the same conditions with regard to length of service as the
survivors of Cannae. As an additional brand of ignominy the men
of both these armies were forbidden to winter in towns or to construct
winter quarters for themselves within ten miles of any town. The
two legions which Q. Mucius had commanded in Sardinia were given
to L. Cornelius, and any additional force he might require was to
be raised by the consuls. T. Otacilius and M. Valerius were ordered
to cruise off the coasts of Sicily and Greece respectively with
the fleets and soldiers they had previously commanded. The former
had a hundred ships with two legions on board; the latter, fifty
ships and one legion. The total strength of the Roman armies engaged
on land and sea this year amounted to twenty-five legions.
26.2
.At the beginning of the year a despatch from L. Marcius was laid
before the senate. The senators fully appreciated the successful
way in which he had conducted his operations, but a good many of
them were indignant at the honorific title he had assumed. The superscription
of the letter was "The propraetor to the senate," though the imperium
had not been conferred upon him by an order of the people nor with
the sanction of the senate. An evil precedent had been set, they
said, when a commander was chosen by his army, and the solemn procedure
at elections, after the auspices were duly taken, was transferred
to camps and provinces far away from the magistrates and the laws,
and left to the caprice of the soldiers. Some thought the senate
ought to take the matter up, but it was thought better to adjourn
the consideration of it until the horsemen who had brought the despatch
had left the City. With regard to the food and clothing of the army,
they ordered a reply to be sent to the effect that both these matters
would be attended to by the senate. They refused, however, to allow
the despatch to be addressed "To the propraetor L. Marcius," lest
it should appear that the question which was to be discussed had
been prejudged. After the messengers had been dismissed the consuls
gave this question priority over everything else, and it was unanimously
agreed that the tribunes should consult the plebs as soon as possible
as to whom they wished to have sent to Spain with the imperium as
commander-in-chief to take over the army which Cn. Scipio had commanded.
The tribunes undertook to do so, and due notice of the question
was given to the Assembly. But the citizens were preoccupied with
a controversy of a very different nature. C. Sempronius Blaesus
had fixed a day for bringing Cn. Fulvius to trial for losing his
army in Apulia, and made a very bitter attack upon him beforehand
in the Assembly. "Many commanders," he said, "have through rashness
and inexperience led their armies into most dangerous positions,
but Cn. Fulvius is the only one who has demoralised his army by
every form of vice before betraying them. They may with perfect
truth be said to have been destroyed before they saw the enemy;
they owed their defeat to their own commander, not to Hannibal.
"Now no man, when he is going to vote, takes sufficient trouble
to find out what sort of a man it is to whom he is entrusting the
supreme command of the army. Think of the difference between Tiberius
Sempronius and Cn. Fulvius. Tiberius Sempronius had an army of slaves
given to him, but in a short time, thanks to the discipline he maintained
and the wise use he made of his authority, there was not a man amongst
them who when he was in the field of battle gave a thought to his
birth or his condition. Those men were a protection to our allies
and a terror to our enemies. They snatched, as though from the very
jaws of Hannibal, cities like Cumae and Beneventum and restored
them to Rome. Cn. Fulvius, on the other hand, had an army of Roman
citizens, born of respectable parents, brought up as free men, and
he infected them with the vices of slaves, and made them such that
they were insolent and riotous amongst our allies, weaklings and
cowards in face of the enemy; they could not stand even the war-cry
of the Carthaginians, let alone their charge. Good heavens! no wonder
the soldiers gave ground, when their commander was the first to
run away; the wonder is that any stood their ground and fell, and
that all did not accompany Cn. Fulvius in his panic and flight.
C. Flaminius, L. Paulus, L. Postumius, and the two Scipios, Cnaeus
and Publius, all chose to fall in battle rather than desert their
armies, when they were hemmed in by the foe. Cn. Fulvius came back
to Rome as the all-but solitary herald of the annihilation of his
army. After the army had fled from the field of Cannae it was deported
to Sicily, not to return till the enemy had evacuated Italy, and
a similar decree was recently passed in the case of Fulvius' legions.
But, shame to relate, the commander himself remained unpunished
after his flight from a battle brought on by his own headstrong
folly; he is free to pass the rest of his life where he passed it
in youth-in stews and brothels-whilst his soldiers, whose only fault
is that they copied their commander, are practically sent into exile
and have to undergo a service of disgrace. So unequal are the liberties
enjoyed in Rome by the rich and the poor, the men of rank and the
men of the people."
26.3
In his defence Fulvius threw all the blame upon his men. They clamoured,
he said, for battle, and he led them out, not at the moment, for
it was late in the day, but on the following morning. Though they
were drawn up on favourable ground, at an early hour they found
either the terror of the enemy's name or the strength of his attack
too much for them. When they were all flying in disorder he was
swept away by the rush as Varro was at Cannae and as many other
commanders have been at different times. What help would he have
given to the republic by staying there alone? unless indeed his
death would have warded off other national disasters. His failure
was not due to lack of supplies, or to incautiously taking up a
position on unfavourable ground; he had not been ambushed through
insufficient reconnoitring; he had been beaten in a fair fight on
an open field. Men's tempers, on whichever side they were, were
beyond his control, a man's natural disposition made him either
brave or cowardly. The speeches of the prosecutor and the defendant
occupied two days, on the third day the witnesses were produced.
Besides all the other serious charges brought against him, a great
many men stated on oath that the panic and flight began with the
praetor, and that when the soldiers found that they were left to
themselves, and thought that their commander had good ground for
fear, they too turned their backs and fled. The prosecutor had in
the first instance asked for a fine, but the evidence which had
been given roused the anger of the people to such an extent that
they insisted upon a capital charge being laid. This led to a fresh
contest. As the prosecutor during the first two days had limited
the penalty to a fine and only on the third day made the charge
a capital one, the defendant appealed to the other tribunes, but
they refused to interfere with their colleague. It was open to him
by ancient custom to proceed either by statute law or by customary
precedent, whichever he preferred, until he had obtained judgment,
whether the penalty were a capital or a pecuniary one. On this Sempronius
announced that he should prosecute C. Fulvius on the charge of treason
and requested the City praetor to convene the Assembly for the purpose
on the appointed day. Then the accused tried another way of escape.
His brother Quintus was in high favour with the people at the time,
owing to his former successes and the general conviction that he
would soon take Capua, and the defendant hoped that he might be
present at his trial. Quintus wrote to the senate for their permission,
appealing to their compassion and begging to be allowed to defend
his brother's life, but they told him in reply that it would militate
against the interests of the State for him to leave Capua. Just
before the day of trial Cn. Fulvius went into exile at Tarquinii.
The plebs affirmed by resolution his legal status as exile and all
the consequences it involved.
26.4
Meanwhile the whole stress of the war bore on Capua. The blockade
was proving more effective than direct assault; the common people
and the slaves could not endure the famine, nor could they send
messengers to Hannibal owing to the strict watch which was kept.
At last a Numidian was found who promised to get through with the
despatches, and he succeeded. He escaped through the Roman lines
by night, and this encouraged the Capuans to attempt sorties in
all directions while they still had some strength left. Numerous
cavalry encounters took place in which they generally had the advantage,
but their infantry got the worst of it. The gratification which
the Romans derived from their infantry successes was considerably
damped by their finding themselves beaten in any arm by an enemy
whom they had invested and almost conquered. At length they devised
a clever plan by which they could make up for their inferiority
in the mounted arm. Young men of exceptional speed and agility were
selected from all the legions and supplied with bucklers somewhat
shorter than those used by the cavalry. Each was furnished with
seven javelins, four feet long and tipped with iron heads similar
to those on the darts of the velites. The troopers each took one
of these upon his horse and trained them to ride behind and leap
down briskly at a given signal. As soon as their daily training
had given them sufficient confidence, the cavalry advanced against
the Capuans, who were drawn up on the level ground between the Roman
camp and the city walls. As soon as they came within range the signal
was given and the velites sprang down to the ground. The line of
infantry thus formed made a sudden attack on the Capuan horse; shower
after shower of javelins was flung at the men and horses all along
the line. A great many were wounded, and the novel and unexpected
form of attack created widespread consternation. Seeing the enemy
shaken the Roman cavalry charged home, and in the rout that followed
they drove them with much loss right up to their gates. From that
time the Romans had the superiority in their cavalry also. The velites
were subsequently incorporated in the legions. This plan of combining
infantry and cavalry in one force is said to have originated with
one of the centurions-Q. Navius, and he received special honour
from his commander in consequence.
26.5
Such was the position of affairs at Capua. During this time Hannibal
was drawn in two directions; he was anxious to get possession of
the citadel of Tarentum and he was equally anxious to retain his
hold on Capua. Regard for Capua however carried the day, for he
saw that it was the spot to which all eyes were turned, of friends
and foes alike, and its fate would show conclusively, one way or
the other, the consequences of defection from Rome. Leaving therefore
his baggage and heavy-armed troops in Bruttium, he hurried into
Campania with a force of horse and foot selected for their capacity
for rapid marching. Swift as his advance was, however, three and
thirty elephants followed him. He took up his position in a secluded
valley at the back of Mount Tifata which overlooked Capua. On his
march he captured the fortified post of Calatia. He then turned
his attention to the besiegers of Capua, and sent a message to the
city telling them at what time he intended to attack the Roman lines,
so that they might be ready to make a sortie and pour in full strength
out of all their gates. The investing force was thrown into a state
of great alarm, for while Hannibal was delivering his assault on
one side, the whole of the forces of Capua, mounted and unmounted,
supported by the Punic garrison under Bostar and Hanno were making
a vigorous sortie on the other. Realising their critical position
and the danger of leaving a portion of their lines unprotected by
concentrating their defence in any one direction, the Romans divided
their force; Appius Claudius confronted the Capuans, Fulvius was
opposed to Hannibal; the propraetor C. Nero with the cavalry of
the six legions held the road to Suessula, and C. Fulvius Flaccus
with the cavalry of the allies took up a position towards the Volturnus.
There was not only the usual shouting and uproar when the battle
commenced; the din of horses and men and arms was aggravated by
the non-combatant population of Capua. They crowded on to the walls,
and by clashing brazen vessels together, as people do in the dead
of the night when there is an eclipse of the moon, they made such
a dreadful noise that it even distracted the attention of the combatants.
Appius had no difficulty in driving the Capuans from his earthworks,
but Fulvius had to meet a much heavier attack from Hannibal and
his Carthaginians on the other side. Here the sixth legion gave
way and a cohort of Spaniards with three elephants succeeded in
getting up to the breastwork. They had penetrated the Roman line,
and whilst they saw their chance of breaking through into the camp
they saw also the danger of being cut off from their supports. When
Fulvius saw the disorder of the legion and the danger which threatened
the camp, he called upon Q. Navius and other centurions of the first
rank to charge the enemy's cohort which was fighting just under
the breastwork. "It is a most critical moment," he told them; "either
you must allow the enemy to go on, in which case they will break
into the camp with less difficulty than they found in breaking through
the closed ranks of the legion, or you must dispose of them whilst
they are still below the breastwork. It will not be a hard fight;
they are a small body, cut off from their support; and the very
fact of the Roman line being broken will be an advantage if both
sections close on the enemy's flanks, who would then be hemmed and
exposed to a double attack." On hearing this Navius took the standard
of the second maniple of hastati from the bearer and advanced with
it against the enemy, threatening at the same time to throw it into
their midst if his men did not promptly follow him and take their
share in the fighting. He was a huge man and his armour set him
off, and as he lifted the standard high in the air, he attracted
all eyes. But when he was close to the Spaniards they hurled their
javelins at him from all sides, and almost the whole of their line
turned their attention to this one man. Neither the number of the
enemy, however, nor the force of their missiles were able to check
the gallant fellow's onset.
26.6
M. Atilius now brought up the leading maniple of the sixth legion
against the Spanish cohort; L. Porcius Licinius and T. Popilius,
who were in command of the camp, were keeping up a fierce struggle
in front of the breastwork, and killed some of the elephants whilst
they were actually clambering over it. Their bodies rolled down
into the fosse and filled it up, making a bridge for the passage
of the enemy, and a terrible carnage began over the prostrate elephants.
On the other side of the camp the Capuans and their Punic garrison
had by this time been repulsed, and the fighting went on right up
to the city gate which leads to the Volturnus. The efforts of the
Romans to break in were frustrated not so much by the arms of the
defenders as by the ballistae and scorpions which were mounted over
the gate and kept the assailants at a distance by the missiles they
discharged. A further check was given them by a wound received by
Appius Claudius; he was struck by a heavy javelin in the upper part
of the chest under the left shoulder, whilst he was riding along
the front encouraging his men. A great many of the enemy were however
killed outside the gate; the rest were driven in hasty flight into
the city. When Hannibal saw the destruction of his Spanish cohort
and the energy with which the Romans were defending their lines,
he gave up the attack and recalled the standards. The retiring column
of infantry was followed by the cavalry who were to protect the
rear in case the enemy harassed their retreat. The legions were
burning to pursue them, but Fulvius ordered the "retire" to be sounded,
as he considered that he had gained quite enough in making both
the Capuans and Hannibal himself realise how little he could do
in their defence.
Some authors who describe this battle say that 8000 of Hannibal's
men were killed that day and 3000 Capuans, and that 15 standards
were taken from the Carthaginians and 18 from the Capuans. In other
accounts I find that the affair was nothing like so serious, there
was more excitement and confusion than actual fighting. According
to these writers the Numidians and Spaniards broke unexpectedly
into the Roman lines with the elephants, and these animals, trotting
all over the camp, upset the tents and created terrible uproar and
panic during which the baggage animals broke their tethers and bolted.
To add to the confusion Hannibal sent some men got up as Italians,
who could speak Latin, to tell the defenders in the name of the
consul that as the camp was lost each man must do his best to escape
to the nearest mountains. The trick was, however, soon detected
and frustrated with heavy loss to the enemy, and the elephants were
driven out of the camp with firebrands. In any case, however it
began or ended, this was the last battle fought before Capua surrendered.
The "medix tuticus," the supreme magistrate of Capua, happened for
that year to be Seppius Loesius, a man of humble birth and slender
fortune. The story goes that owing to a portent which had occurred
in his mother's household she consulted a soothsayer on behalf of
her little boy, and he told her that the highest official position
in Capua would come to her son. As she was not aware of anything
which would justify such expectations she replied, "You are indeed
describing a desperate state of things in Capua when you say that
such an honour will come to my son." Her jesting reply to what was
a true prediction turned out itself to be true, for it was only
when famine and sword were pressing them sorely and all hope of
further resistance was disappearing that Loesius accepted the post.
He was the last Capuan to hold it, and he only did so under protest;
Capua, he declared, was abandoned and betrayed by all her foremost
citizens.
26.7
Finding that his enemy could not be drawn into an engagement and
that it was impossible to break through their lines and relieve
Capua, Hannibal decided to abandon his attempt and march away from
the place, for he was afraid of being cut off from his supplies
by the new consuls. He was anxiously turning over in his mind the
question of his future movements when the idea occurred to him of
marching upon Rome, the head and guiding spirit of the whole war.
He had always set his heart upon this, and men blamed him for letting
the opportunity slip, immediately after the battle of Cannae; he
himself admitted that he had made a mistake in not doing so. He
was not without hope of seizing some part of the City in the confusion
caused by his unexpected appearance, and if Rome were in danger,
he expected that both the consuls-or at all events, one of them-would
at once quit their hold on Capua. Then, as they would be weakened
by their forces being divided, they would give either him or the
Capuans the opportunity of fighting a successful action. One thing
made him anxious, the possibility of the Capuans surrendering as
soon as he had withdrawn. Amongst his men there was a Numidian who
was ready for any desperate enterprise, and he induced this man,
by the offer of a reward, to carry a despatch and enter the Roman
lines in the guise of a deserter, then steal away on the opposite
side and enter Capua. He wrote in a very encouraging strain, and
pointed out that his departure would be the means of saving them,
as it would draw off the Roman generals from their attack on Capua
to defend Rome. They were not to be despondent, a few days' patience
would completely break up the siege. He then ordered the boats which
were on the Volturnus to be seized and brought up to a fort which
he had previously constructed to secure the passage of the river.
He was informed that there was a sufficient number of them to admit
of his entire army being taken across in one night. Ten days' rations
were supplied to the men; they marched down to the river, and all
his legions were across before day-break.
26.8
Fulvius Flaccus was informed by deserters of this project before
it was put into execution, and at once sent intelligence of it to
the senate. The news was received with varying feelings as men's
temperaments differed. Naturally, at such a crisis, a meeting of
the senate was instantly convened. Publius Cornelius Asina was for
recalling all the generals and armies from every part of Italy for
the defence of the City, regardless of Capua or any other object
they had in view. Fabius Maximus considered that it would be a disgrace
for them to quit their hold on Capua and allow themselves to be
scared by Hannibal and marched up and down at his beck and menaces.
"Do you suppose," he asked the senators, "that the man who did not
venture to approach the City after his victory at Cannae, really
hopes to capture it now that he has been driven away from Capua?
His object in coming here is not to attack Rome but to raise the
siege of Capua. The army which is now in the City will be sufficient
for our defence, for it will be aided by Jupiter and the other gods
who have witnessed Hannibal's violation of treaty engagements."
P. Valerius Flaccus advocated a middle course, which was ultimately
adopted. He recommended that a despatch should be sent to the generals
commanding at Capua, telling them what defensive force the City
possessed. They themselves would know what troops Hannibal was bringing
and how large an army was required to maintain the siege of Capua.
If one of the generals commanding could be sent with a part of the
army to Rome without interfering with the effective conduct of the
siege by the other general, Claudius and Fulvius might arrange which
of them should continue the investment of Capua and which should
go to Rome to prevent their own city from being invested. When this
decision of the senate reached Capua, the proconsul Q. Fulvius,
whose colleague had been obliged to leave for Rome owing to his
wound, selected a force out of the three armies and crossed the
Volturnus with 15,000 infantry and 1000 cavalry. When he had definitely
ascertained that Hannibal was advancing by the Latin Road, he sent
men on in advance through the burghs situated on the Appian Way
and also to some lying near it, to warn the inhabitants to have
supplies stored in readiness in their towns and to bring them in
from the outlying fields to the line of march. They were further
to call in their fighting men to defend their homes, and each municipality
was to provide for its own protection.
26.9
After crossing the Volturnus Hannibal fixed his camp a short distance
from the river, and the next day he marched past Cales into the
Sidicine territory. One day was devoted to laying waste the district,
and then he proceeded along the Latin Road through the lands of
Suessa, Allifae, and Casinum up to the walls of the last-mentioned
place. Here he remained encamped for two days and ravaged the whole
of the surrounding country. From there he went on past Interamna
and Aquinum into the territory of Fregellae as far as the Liris.
Here he found that the bridge had been destroyed by the people of
Fregellae in order to delay his advance. Fulvius too had been delayed
at the Volturnus, owing to Hannibal having burnt his boats, and
he had considerable difficulty in procuring rafts for the transport
of his troops, owing to the lack of timber. When, however, he had
once crossed, the remainder of his march was uninterrupted, as he
found ample supplies of provisions waiting for him in each city
he came to, and also put out by the side of the road in the country
districts. His men, too, in their eagerness urged one another to
march more quickly, for they were going to defend their homes. A
messenger who had travelled from Fregellae for a day and a night
without stopping created great alarm in Rome, and the excitement
was increased by people running about the City with wildly exaggerated
accounts of the news he had brought. The wailing cry of the matrons
was heard everywhere, not only in private houses but even in the
temples. Here they knelt and swept the temple-floors with their
dishevelled hair and lifted up their hands to heaven in piteous
entreaty to the gods that they would deliver the City of Rome out
of the hands of the enemy and preserve its mothers and children
from injury and outrage. The senators remained in session in the
Forum so as to be at hand should the magistrates wish to consult
them. Some received orders and went off to execute their commissions,
others offered their services in case they could be of use anywhere.
Troops were posted at the Capitol, on the walls, round about the
City and even as far as the Alban Mount and the fortress of Aesula.
In the midst of all this excitement word was brought that the proconsul
Q. Fulvius was on his way from Capua with an army. As proconsul
he could not hold command in the City, the senate therefore passed
a decree conferring upon him consular powers. After completely destroying
the territory of Fregellae in revenge for the destruction of the
bridge over the Liris, Hannibal continued his march through the
districts of Frusinum, Ferentinum and Anagnia into the neighbourhood
of Labicum. He then crossed Algidus and marched on Tusculum, but
he was refused admittance, so he turned to the right below Tusculum
towards Gabii, and still descending, came into the district of Pupinia
where he encamped, eight miles from Rome. The nearer his approach
the greater was the slaughter of those who were fleeing to the City
at the hands of the Numidians who rode in front of the main body.
Many, too, of all ages and conditions were made prisoners.
26.10
In the midst of this turmoil and excitement Fulvius Flaccus entered
Rome with his army. He passed through the Porta Capena and marched
right through the City past the Cavinae and the Esquiliae, and out
again through the Colline Gate, entrenching himself on ground between
the Colline and Esquiline Gates. Here the plebeian aediles furnished
him with provisions. The consuls, attended by the senate, visited
him in his camp, and a council was held to consider what measures
the supreme interests of the republic demanded. It was decided that
the consuls should form entrenched camps in the vicinity of the
Colline and Esquiline Gates, the City praetor taking command of
the Citadel and the Capitol, and that the senate should remain in
permanent session in the Forum in case any sudden emergency should
need to be provided against. Hannibal had now moved his camp to
the Anio at a distance of three miles from the City. From this position,
he advanced with a body of 2000 cavalry towards the Colline Gate
as far as the temple of Hercules, and from that point he rode up
and made as close an inspection as he could of the walls and the
situation of the City. Flaccus was furious with indignation at this
calm and leisurely proceeding and sent some cavalry with orders
to clear the enemy and drive them back to their camp. There were
some 1200 Numidian deserters stationed on the Aventine at the time,
and the consuls sent orders to them to ride through the City to
the Esquiliae, as they considered none more fitted to fight amongst
the hollows and garden walls and sepulchres and enclosed paths all
around that part of the City. When those on guard at the Citadel
and the Capitol saw them trotting down the Publician hill they shouted
out that the Aventine was taken. This caused so much confusion and
panic that, had not the Carthaginian camp been outside the City,
the terrified population would have poured out of the gates. As
it was, they took refuge in the houses and various buildings, and
seeing some of their own people walking in the streets, they took
them for enemies and attacked them with stones and missiles. It
was impossible to calm the excitement or to rectify the mistake,
as the streets were packed with crowds of country people with their
cattle, whom the sudden danger had driven into the City. The cavalry
action was successful and the enemy were driven off. It became necessary,
however, to quell the disturbances which, without the slightest
reason, were breaking out in many quarters, and the senate decided
that all who had been Dictators, consuls or censors should be invested
with the imperium until the enemy had retired from the walls. During
the remainder of the day and throughout the night, many such disturbances
arose and were promptly repressed.
26.11
The following day Hannibal crossed the Anio and led out the whole
of his force to battle; Flaccus and the consuls did not decline
the challenge. When both sides were drawn up to decide an action
in which Rome was the victor's prize, a tremendous hailstorm threw
the two armies into such disorder that they had difficulty in holding
their arms. They retired to their respective camps, fearing everything
rather than their enemy. The following day, when the armies were
drawn up in the same position, a similar storm separated them. On
each occasion, after they were once more in camp, the weather cleared
up in an extraordinary way. The Carthaginians looked upon the occasion
as preternatural, and the story runs that Hannibal was heard to
say that at one time he lacked the will, at another the opportunity,
of becoming master of Rome. His hopes were further damped by two
incidents, one of some importance, the other less so. The more important
was his receiving information that while he was actually in arms
near the walls of Rome a force had marched out fully equipped, under
their standards, to reinforce the army in Spain. The other incident,
which he learnt from a prisoner, was the sale by auction of the
spot on which he had fixed his camp, and the fact that, in spite
of his occupation of it, there was no abatement in the price. That
any one should have been found in Rome to buy the ground which he
was holding in possession as spoil of war, seemed to Hannibal such
an insulting piece of arrogance that he instantly summoned a crier
and made him give notice of the sale of the silversmiths' shops
round the Forum of Rome.
These incidents led to his withdrawal from Rome, and he retired
as far as the river Tutia, six miles distant from the City. From
there he marched to the grove of Feronia and the temple, which was
celebrated in those days for its wealth. The people of Capena and
other cities round used to bring their first-fruits and other offerings,
according to their ability, and they had also embellished it with
a considerable quantity of gold and silver. Now the temple was despoiled
of all its treasures. Great heaps of metal, where the soldiers,
struck by remorse, had thrown pieces of uncoined brass, were found
there after Hannibal's departure. All writers are agreed as to the
plundering of this temple. Coelius tell us that Hannibal diverted
his march to it while he was going from Eretum to Rome, after marching
from Amiternum by Reate and Cutiliae. According to this writer,
on leaving Capua, Hannibal entered Samnium, and from there passed
to the Peligni; then, marching past the town of Sulmo, he crossed
the frontiers of the Marrucini and then advanced through the Alban
territory to the country of the Marsi, and from there to Amiternum
and the hamlet of Foruli. There can be no uncertainty as to the
route he took, for the traces of that great commander and his large
army could not have been lost in so short a space of time; the only
point at issue is whether that was the route he took when he marched
to Rome or whether he followed it on his return to Campania.
26.12
The energy with which the Romans pressed the siege of Capua was
far greater than that which Hannibal exhibited in its defence, for
he hurried away through Lucania to Bruttium in the hope of surprising
Regium. Though the siege was in no way relaxed during Fulvius' absence,
his return made a sensible difference in the conduct of operations,
and it was a matter of general surprise that Hannibal had not returned
at the same time. The Capuans gradually learnt through their conversations
with the besiegers that they were abandoned and left to themselves,
and that the Carthaginians had given up all hope of saving Capua.
In accordance with a resolution of the senate, the proconsul issued
an edict which was published in the city, that any Campanian burgher
who went over to the Romans before a certain day would be amnestied.
Not a single man went over; their fears prevented them from trusting
the Romans, for they had in their revolt committed crimes too great
for any hope of pardon. But whilst no one would provide for his
own safety by going over to the enemy, there was nothing done for
the public safety in the way of wise or prudent counsel. The nobility
had deserted their public duties; it was impossible to get together
a meeting of the senate. The supreme magistracy was held by a man
who conferred no honour on his office; on the contrary, his unfitness
detracted from its authority and power. None of the nobility were
to be seen in the forum, or indeed anywhere in public; they shut
themselves up at home waiting for their country's downfall and their
own destruction. All responsibility was thrown upon the commandants
of the Punic garrison, Bostar and Hanno, and they were much more
concerned for their own safety than for that of their supporters
in the city. A communication was drawn up for the purpose of forwarding
it to Hannibal, in which he was directly charged with surrendering
Capua into the enemy's hands and exposing his garrison to every
kind of torture. He had gone off, so the despatch hinted, to be
out of the way, lest Capua should be taken before his eyes, The
Romans could not be drawn off from besieging Capua even when an
attack was threatened on their city; so much more determination
did the Romans show as enemies, than the Carthaginians as friends.
If Hannibal would return to Capua and turn the whole tide of war
in that direction, then the garrison were prepared to make an attack
on the besiegers. He had not crossed the Alps to make war with Regium
or Tarentum; where the legions of Rome were, there ought the armies
of Carthage to be. That was how he had conquered at Cannae, and
at Thrasymenus, by meeting the enemy face to face, army to army,
and trying his fortune in battle.
This was the main drift of the despatch. It was handed to some
Numidians who had undertaken to carry it on promise of a reward.
They had come into Fulvius' camp as deserters, intending to seize
a favourable opportunity of slipping away, and the famine from which
Capua had long been suffering was a very good reason why they should
desert. A Campanian woman, however, the mistress of one of these
deserters, suddenly appeared in the camp and informed the Roman
commander that the Numidians had come in as part of a pre-arranged
plot, and were really carrying a despatch to Hannibal, and that
she was prepared to prove it, as one of them had disclosed the affair
to her. When this man was brought forward, he at first stoutly denied
all knowledge of the woman, but gradually he gave way before the
truth, especially when he saw that instruments of torture were being
sent for and got ready, and at last made a complete confession.
The despatch was produced, and further evidence came to light, as
it was found that other Numidians were at large in the Roman camp
under the guise of deserters. Above seventy of them were arrested
and together with the recent arrivals were all scourged, and their
hands were cut off, after which they were sent back to Capua. The
sight of this terrible punishment broke the spirit of the Capuans.
26.13
The people went in a body to the senate house and insisted on Loesius
summoning the senate. They openly threatened the nobles who had
so long absented themselves from the senate, that they would go
round to their houses and drag them all by main force into the streets.
These threats resulted in a full meeting of the senate. The general
opinion was in favour of sending a deputation to the Roman commander,
but Vibius Virrius, the prime author of the revolt from Rome, when
asked his opinion, told those who were talking about a deputation
and terms of peace and surrender that they were forgetting what
they would have done had they had the Romans in their power, or
what, as circumstances now were, they would have to suffer. "Why!
," he exclaimed, "do you imagine that our surrender now will be
like the one we made in old days when, in order to get help against
the Samnites, we surrendered ourselves and all that belonged to
us to Rome? Have you already forgotten at what a critical moment
for Rome we revolted from her? How we put to death with every torture
and indignity the garrison which we could easily have sent away?
What numerous and desperate sorties we have made against our besiegers,
how we have assaulted their lines and called Hannibal in to crush
them? Have you forgotten this last act of ours when we sent him
to attack Rome ?
"Now look at the other side, consider their determined hostility
to us and see if you have anything to hope for. Though there was
a foreign enemy on Italian soil, and that enemy Hannibal, though
the flames of war were being kindled in every quarter, they neglected
everything, even Hannibal himself, and sent both the consuls, each
with an army, to Capua. For two years now have they hemmed us in
with their lines of circumvallation, and are wearing us down with
famine. They have endured as much as we have in the extremity of
peril, the utmost severity of toil; often have they been slaughtered
about their entrenchments, and all but driven out of them. But I
pass over these things; the labours and dangers of a siege are an
old and common experience. But to show their rage and implacable
hatred against us I will remind you of these incidents: Hannibal
assaulted their lines with an enormous force of infantry and cavalry,
and partly captured them, but they did not raise the siege; he crossed
the Volturnus and desolated the district of Calenum with fire; the
sufferings of their allies failed to call off the Romans; he ordered
a general advance on Rome itself, they disregarded the threatening
storm; he crossed the Anio and encamped within three miles of the
City, and at last rode up to its walls and gates and made as though
he would take their city from them if they did not loose their hold
on Capua; they did not loose their hold. When wild beasts are mad
with rage you can still divert their blind fury by approaching their
lairs and young ones which they will hasten to defend. The Romans
were not diverted from Capua by the prospect of their city being
besieged, or by the terrified cries of their wives and children
which could almost be heard here, or by the threatened desecration
of their hearths and altars, of the shrines of their gods and the
tombs of their ancestors. So eager are they to visit us with punishment,
so greedily do they thirst for our blood. And, perhaps, rightly;
we should have done the same had fortune favoured us.
"Heaven, however, has ordered otherwise, and so, though I am bound
to meet my death in any case, I can, whilst I am still free, escape
the insults and the tortures which the enemy is preparing for me,
I can dispose of myself by a death as peaceful as it is honourable.
I refuse to look upon Appius Claudius and Q. Fulvius exulting in
all the insolence of victory; I refuse to be dragged in chains through
the streets of Rome to grace their triumph, and then in the dungeon
or bound to the stake, with my back torn with the scourge, pass
under the headsman's axe. I will not see my city plundered and burnt,
and the matrons and maidens and noble boys of Capua ravished and
outraged. Alba, the mother city of Rome, was rased by the Romans
to its foundations in order that no memorial of their origin and
of the stock whence they sprung might survive; much less can I believe
that they will spare Capua which they hate more bitterly than they
hate Carthage. So, for those of you who intend to meet your fate
before you witness all these horrors I have prepared a banquet today
at my house. When you have taken your fill of food and wine, the
same goblet that is handed to me will be passed round to you. That
draught will free our bodies from torture, our spirits from insult,
our eyes and ears from seeing and hearing all the suffering and
outrage which await the vanquished. Men will be in readiness to
place our lifeless bodies on a vast pile which will be kindled in
the court-yard of the house. This is the only path to death which
is honourable and worthy of free men. Even the enemy will admire
our courage, and Hannibal will know that the allies whom he has
abandoned and betrayed were, after all, brave men."
26.14
This speech of Virrius was received with approbation by many who
had not the courage to carry out what they approved of. The majority
of the senators were not without hope that the clemency of the Roman
people so often experienced in former wars would be once more extended
to them, and they determined to send envoys to make a formal surrender
of Capua. About seven-and-twenty accompanied Virrius home and banqueted
with him. When they had as far as possible deadened their feelings
with wine against the sense of impending evil, they all partook
of the poisoned cup. Then they rose from table and grasped each
other's hands and took a last embrace of one another, weeping for
their own and their country's doom. Some remained that they might
be cremated together on the same funeral pyre, others departed for
their homes. The congestion of the veins caused by the food and
wine they had taken made the action of the poison somewhat slow,
and most of them lingered through the whole night and part of the
following day. All however, expired before the gates were opened
to the enemy. The following day, the gate called "the Gate of Jupiter,"
opposite the Roman camp, was opened by the proconsul's order. One
legion was admitted through it and two squadrons of allied cavalry,
with C. Fulvius in command. First he took care that all the weapons
of war in Capua were brought to him; then, after stationing guards
at all the gates to prevent any exit or escape, he arrested the
Punic garrison and ordered the senate to go to the Roman commanders.
On their arrival in the camp they were manacled, and ordered to
send word for all the gold and silver they possessed to be brought
to the quaestors. This amounted to 2072 pounds of gold and 31,200
pounds of silver. Twenty-five senators were sent to be kept in custody
at Cales, and twenty-eight who were proved to have been mainly instrumental
in bringing about the revolt were sent to Teanum
26.15
As to the punishment to be meted out to the senators of Capua,
Claudius and Fulvius were anything but unanimous. Claudius was prepared
to grant them pardon, but Fulvius took a much sterner line. Appius
Claudius wished to refer the whole question to the senate at Rome.
He maintained that it was but right that the senators should have
an opportunity of investigating all the circumstances and finding
out whether the Capuans had made any of the allies or the Latins
or the municipal burghs privy to their designs, and if so, whether
any of these had given them assistance in the war. Fulvius, on the
other hand, declared that the very last thing they ought to do was
to harass their faithful allies by vague charges and put them at
the mercy of informers who were perfectly indifferent as to what
they said or what they did. Any such investigation therefore he
should stifle. After this interchange of views they parted, Appius
feeling no doubt that in spite of his violent language his comrade
would, in such an important matter, await instructions from Rome.
Fulvius, determined to forestall any such obstacle to his designs,
dismissed the council and ordered the military tribunes and the
officers of the allies to select 2000 horsemen and warn them to
be in readiness by the time the third watch was sounded. Starting
with this force in the night, he reached Teanum at day-break and
rode straight into the forum. A crowd had collected at the first
entry of the cavalry, and Fulvius ordered the chief magistrate of
the district to be summoned, and on his appearance commanded him
to produce the Capuans who were in his custody. They were all brought
forward and then scourged and beheaded. Then putting spurs to his
horse he rode to Cales. When he had taken his seat on the tribunal
and the Capuans who had been brought out were being bound to the
stake, a mounted messenger arrived post-haste from Rome and handed
Fulvius a despatch from the praetor C. Calpurnius containing the
decree of the senate. The spectators guessed the nature of the contents,
and those standing round the tribunal expressed their belief-a belief
which soon found expression throughout the Assembly-that the whole
question of the treatment of the Capuan prisoners was to be left
to the senate. Fulvius thought so too; he took the letter and without
opening it placed it in his breast and then ordered his marshal
to tell the lictor to carry out the law. Thus, those who were at
Cales were also executed. Now he read the despatch and the decree
of the senate. But it was too late to prevent a deed accomplished,
which had been hurried on as quickly as possible in order that it
might not be prevented. Just as Fulvius was leaving the tribunal
a Capuan named Taurea Vibellius strode through the middle of the
crowd and addressed him by name. Fulvius resumed his seat, wondering
what the man wanted. "Order me too," he cried, to be put to death
so that you may boast of having caused the death of a braver man
than yourself." Fulvius declared that the man was certainly out
of his mind, and added that even if he wished to kill him he was
prevented from doing so by the decree of the senate. Then Vibellius
exclaimed, "Now that my native city has been taken, my friends and
relations lost to me, my wife and children slain by my own hand
to save them from insult and outrage, and since even the opportunity
of dying as my fellow-countrymen here have died is refused me, let
me seek in courage a release from the life which has become so hateful
to me." With these words he drew out a sword which he had concealed
in his garment, and plunging it into his heart fell dying at the
general's feet.
26.16
As the execution of the Capuans and most of the other steps taken
were carried out by the instructions of Fulvius alone, some authors
assert that Appius Claudius died immediately after the surrender
of Capua. According to this account, Taurea did not come voluntarily
to Cales, nor did he perish by his own hand; when he had been tied
to the stake along with the others he shouted repeatedly, and as
owing to the noise they could not hear what he was saying, Fulvius
ordered silence. Then Taurea said, as I have already related, that
he was being done to death by a man who was far from being his equal
in courage. At these words, the marshal, on the proconsul's order
gave this direction to the lictor: "Lictor, let this brave man have
more of the rod, and execute the law upon him first of all." Some
authors assert that the decree of the senate was read before the
men were beheaded, but there was a proviso in it to the effect that
if he thought fit, he might refer the question to the senate, and
Fulvius took this to mean that he was at liberty to decide as to
what would be the best course in the interests of the republic.
After Fulvius returned to Capua, he received the submission of Atella
and Calatia. Here too the ringleaders in the revolt were punished;
seventy of the leading senators were put to death, and three hundred
Campanian nobles thrown into prison. Others who were distributed
amongst the various Latin cities to be kept in custody perished
from various causes; the rest of the population of Capua were sold
as slaves. The question now was what was to be done with the city
and its territory. Some were of opinion that a city so strong, so
near to Rome and so hostile to it, ought to be utterly destroyed.
Utilitarian considerations however prevailed. The territory was
generally allowed to be the first in Italy in point of productiveness,
and the only reason why the city was spared was that there might
be a place for the tillers of the soil to live in. A motley throng
of peasants, freedmen, small tradesmen and artisans were told off
to occupy the place; the whole of the territory with the buildings
on it became the property of the Roman State. It was settled that
Capua itself should be simply a lodgment and a shelter, a city merely
in name; there was to be no corporate life, no senate, no council
of the plebs, no magistrates; the population were without any right
of public assembly or self-government; they had no common interest
and were incapable of taking any common action. The administration
of justice was in the hands of a praetor who was to be sent annually
from Rome. In this way matters were arranged at Capua in pursuance
of a policy which commends itself from every point of view. Sternly
and swiftly was punishment meted out to those who had been most
guilty, the civic population was scattered far and wide with no
hope of return, the unoffending walls and houses were spared from
the ravages of fire and demolition. The preservation of the city,
whilst it was a material advantage to Rome, afforded to the friendly
communities a striking proof of her lenity; the whole of Campania
and all the surrounding nationalities would have been horror-struck
at the destruction of such a famous and wealthy city. The enemy,
on the other hand, was made to realise the power of Rome to punish
those who were faithless to her, and the powerlessness of Hannibal
to protect those who had gone over to him.
26.17
Now that the senate was relieved from its anxiety about Capua,
it was able to turn its attention to Spain. A force of 6000 infantry
and 300 cavalry was placed at Nero's disposal, and he selected it
from the two legions he had had with him at Capua; an equal number
of infantry and 600 cavalry were to be furnished by the allies.
He embarked his army at Puteoli and landed at Tarraco. Here he hauled
his ships ashore and furnished the crews with arms, thus augmenting
his strength. With this composite force he marched to the Ebro and
took over the army there from Ti. Fonteius and L. Marcius. He then
advanced against the enemy. Hasdrubal-Hamilcar's son-was encamped
at the Lapides Atri (the "Black Boulders"). This is a place in the
Auretanian country between the towns of Iliturgis and Mentissa.
Nero occupied the two exits of the pass. Hasdrubal, finding himself
shut in, sent a herald to promise in his name that he would deport
the whole of his army from Spain if he were allowed to leave his
position. The Roman general was glad to accept the offer, and Hasdrubal
asked for an interview the following day. At this conference they
were to draw up in writing the terms upon which the various citadels
were to be handed over, and the date at which the garrisons were
to be withdrawn, on the understanding that they should take with
them all their goods and chattels.
His request was granted, and Hasdrubal ordered the most heavily
armed portion of his army to get out of the pass as best they could
as soon as darkness set in. He was careful to see that not very
many went out that night, as a small body would make but little
noise and be more likely to escape observation. They would also
find their way more easily through the narrow and difficult foot-paths.
The next day he kept the appointment, but so much time was taken
up in discussing and writing down a number of things which had nothing
to do with the matters they had agreed to discuss, that the whole
day was lost and the business adjourned till the morrow. So another
opportunity was afforded him of sending off a fresh body of troops
by night. The discussion was not brought to a close the next day,
and so it went on; several days were occupied in discussing terms,
and the nights in despatching the Carthaginians secretly from their
camp. When the greater part of the army had escaped, Hasdrubal no
longer kept to the conditions which he had himself proposed, and
there was less and less desire to come to terms as his sincerity
diminished with his fears. Almost the entire force of infantry had
now got out of the defile when, at daybreak, a dense fog covered
the valley and the whole of the surrounding country. No sooner did
Hasdrubal become aware of this than he sent a message to Nero begging
that the interview might be put off for that day as it was a day
on which the Carthaginians were forbidden by their religion to transact
any important business. Even this did not arouse any suspicion of
trickery. On learning that he would be excused for that day, Hasdrubal
promptly left his camp with the cavalry and elephants, and by keeping
his movements secret, emerged into safety. About ten o'clock the
sun dispersed the mist, and the Romans saw that the hostile camp
was deserted. Then, recognising at last the trick which the Carthaginian
had played upon him and how he had been befooled, Nero hurriedly
prepared to follow him and force him to an engagement. The enemy,
however, declined battle; only a few skirmishes took place between
the Carthaginian rear and the Roman advanced guard.
26.18
The Spanish tribes who had revolted after the defeat of the two
Scipios showed no signs of returning to their allegiance; there
were not, however, any fresh instances. After the recovery of Capua
the public interest both in senate and people centered in Spain
quite as much as in Italy; and it was decided that the army serving
there should be increased and a commander-in-chief appointed. There
was, however, much uncertainty felt as to whom they ought to appoint.
Two consummate generals had fallen within thirty days of each other,
and the selection of a man to take their place demanded exceptional
care. Various names were proposed, and at last it was arranged that
the matter should be left to the people, and a proconsul for Spain
formally elected. The consuls fixed a day for the election. They
were in hopes that those who felt themselves qualified for such
an important command would become candidates. They were, however,
disappointed, and the disappointment renewed the grief of the people,
as they thought of the defeats they had sustained and the generals
they had lost. The citizens were depressed, almost in despair, nevertheless
they went out to the Campus Martius on the day fixed for the election.
All turned their eyes to the magistrates and watched the expression
of the leaders of the republic as they looked enquiringly at one
another. Everywhere men were saying that the State was in such a
hopeless condition that no one dared to accept the command in Spain.
Suddenly, Publius Cornelius Scipio, the son of the Scipio who had
fallen in Spain, a young man barely twenty-four years old, took
his stand upon a slight eminence where he could be seen and heard,
and announced himself as a candidate. All eyes were turned towards
him, and the delighted cheers with which his announcement was received
were at once interpreted as an omen of his future good fortune and
success. On proceeding to vote, not only the centuries but even
the individual voters were unanimous to a man in favour of entrusting
P. Scipio with the supreme command in Spain. When, however, the
election was decided and their enthusiasm had had time to cool down,
there was a sudden silence as the people began to reflect on what
they had done, and ask themselves whether their personal affection
for him might not have got the better of their judgment. What gave
them the greatest concern was his youth. Some, too, recalled with
dread the fortune that had attended his house, and regarded as ominous
of evil even the name of the man who was quitting two bereaved families
in order to carry on a campaign round the tombs of his uncle and
his father.
26.19
Seeing how the step which they had taken so impetuously now filled
them with anxiety, Scipio called the voters together and spoke to
them about his age and the command which they had entrusted to him,
and the war which he had to conduct. He spoke in such lofty and
glowing words that he evoked their enthusiasm once more, and inspired
them with more hopeful confidence than is usually called out by
faith in men's promises or by reasonable anticipations of success.
Scipio won people's admiration not only by the sterling qualities
which he possessed, but also by his cleverness in displaying them,
a cleverness which he had developed from early youth. In his public
life he generally spoke and acted as though he were guided either
by visions of the night or by some divine inspiration, whether it
was that he was really open to superstitious influences or that
he claimed oracular sanction for his commands and counsels in order
to secure prompt adoption. He sought to create this impression on
men's minds from the beginning, from the day when he assumed the
toga virilis, for he never undertook any important business, either
public or private, without first going to the Capitol, where he
sat for some time in the temple in privacy and alone. This custom,
which he kept up all through his life, gave rise to a widespread
belief, whether designedly upon his part or not, that he was of
divine origin, and the story was told of him which was commonly
related of Alexander-a story as silly as it was fabulous-that he
was begotten by an enormous serpent which had been often seen in
his mother's bedroom, but on any one's approach, suddenly uncoiled
itself and disappeared. The belief in these marvels was never scoffed
at by him; on the contrary, it was strengthened by deliberate policy
on his part in refusing to deny or to admit that anything of the
kind ever occurred. There were many other traits in this young man's
character, some of which were genuine, others the result of studied
acting, which created a greater admiration for him than usually
falls to the lot of man.
It was the confidence with which he had in this way inspired his
fellow-citizens that led them to entrust to him, young as he was,
a task of enormous difficulty, and a command which involved the
gravest responsibilities. The force which he had formed out of the
old army in Spain, and that which sailed from Puteoli with C. Nero,
were further reinforced by 10,000 infantry and 1000 cavalry. M.
Junius Silanus was appointed as his second in command. Setting sail
from the mouth of the Tiber with a fleet of thirty vessels, all
quinqueremes, he coasted along the Etruscan shore, crossed the Gulf
of Gaul, and after rounding the Pyrenaean Promontory brought up
at Emporiae, a Greek city, founded by settlers from Phocaea. Here
he disembarked his troops and proceeded overland to Tarraco, leaving
orders for his fleet to follow his movements. At Tarraco he was
met by deputations which had been sent from all the friendly tribes
as soon as they knew of his coming. The vessels were hauled ashore,
and the four Massilian triremes which had acted as convoy were sent
home. The deputations informed Scipio of the unsettlement amongst
their tribes due to the varying fortunes of the war. He replied
in a bold and assured tone, full of self-confidence, but no expression
savouring of presumption or arrogance escaped him, everything he
said was marked by perfect dignity and sincerity.
26.20
Tarraco was now his headquarters. From there he paid visits to
the friendly tribes, and also inspected the winter quarters of the
army. He praised them warmly for having maintained their hold on
the province after sustaining two such terrible blows, and also
for keeping the enemy to the south of the Ebro, thereby depriving
them of any advantages from their victories, and also affording
protection to their own friends. Marcius, whom he kept with him,
he treated with so much honour that it was perfectly obvious that
Scipio had not the slightest fear of his reputation being dimmed
by anybody. Soon afterwards Silanus succeeded Nero and the new troops
were sent into winter quarters. After making all the necessary visits
and inspections and completing the preparations for the next campaign
Scipio returned to Tarraco. His reputation was quite as great among
the enemy as among his own countrymen; there was amongst the former
a foreboding, a vague sense of fear which was all the stronger because
no reason for it could be given. The Carthaginian armies withdrew
into their respective winter-quarters: Hasdrubal, the son of Gisgo,
to Gades on the coast, Mago into the interior above the forest of
Castulo, Hasdrubal, the son of Hamilcar, near the Ebro in the neighbourhood
of Saguntum. This summer, marked by two important events, the recovery
of Capua and the despatch of Scipio to Spain, was drawing to a close
when a Carthaginian fleet was sent from Sicily to Tarentum to intercept
supplies from the Roman garrison in the citadel. It certainly succeeded
in blocking all access to the citadel from the sea, but the longer
it remained the greater was the scarcity amongst the townspeople
as compared with that amongst the Romans in the citadel. For though
the coast was clear and open access was secured to the harbour by
the Carthaginian fleet, it was impossible to convey to the population
of the city as much corn as was consumed by the crowd of sailors,
drawn from every class, on board the fleet. The garrison in the
citadel, on the other hand, being only a small body, were able to
exist on what they had previously laid in, without any external
supply. At length the ships were sent away, and their departure
was hailed with more delight than their arrival had been. But the
scarcity was not in the slightest degree lessened, for when their
protection was withdrawn, corn could not be brought in at all.
26.21
Towards the end of this summer M. Marcellus left Sicily for Rome.
On his arrival in the City he was granted an audience of the senate
in the Temple of Bellona. After giving a report of his campaign
and gently protesting on his own behalf and on that of his soldiers
against not being allowed to bring them home, though he had completely
pacified the province, he requested to be allowed to enter the City
in triumph. After a lengthy debate his request was refused. On the
one hand, it was argued, it was most inconsistent to refuse him
a triumph now that he was on the spot after the way in which the
news of his successes in Sicily had been received, and public thanksgivings
and special rites ordered while he was still in his province. Against
this it was alleged that as the senate had ordered him to hand over
his army to his successor, it was a proof that a state of war still
existed in the province, and he could not enjoy a triumph since
he had not brought the war to a close, nor was his army present
to testify as to whether he deserved a triumph or not. They decided
upon a middle course, he was to be allowed an ovation. The tribunes
of the plebs were authorised by the senate to propose as an ordinance
to the people "that for the day on which he entered the City in
ovation M. Marcellus should retain his command."
The day previous to this he celebrated his triumph on the Alban
Mount. From there he marched into the City in ovation. An enormous
quantity of spoil was carried before him together with a model of
Syracuse at the time of its capture. Catapults and ballistae and
all the engines of war taken from the city were exhibited in the
procession, as were also the works of art which had been accumulated
in royal profusion during the long years of peace. These included
a number of articles in silver and bronze, pieces of furniture,
costly garments and many famous statues with which Syracuse, like
all the principal cities of Greece, had been adorned. To signalise
his victories over the Carthaginians eight elephants were led in
the procession. Not the least conspicuous feature of the spectacle
was the sight of Sosis the Syracusan and Moericus the Spaniard who
marched in front wearing golden crowns. The former had guided the
nocturnal entry into Syracuse, the latter had been the agent in
the surrender of Nasos and its garrison. Each of these men received
the full Roman citizenship and 500 jugera of land. Sosis was to
take his allotment in that part of the Syracusan territory which
had belonged to the king or to those who had taken up arms against
Rome, and he was allowed to choose any house in Syracuse which had
been the property of those who had been put to death under the laws
of war. A further order was made that Moericus and the Spaniards
should have assigned to them a city and lands in Sicily out of the
possessions of those who had revolted from Rome. M. Cornelius was
commissioned to select the city and territory for them, where he
thought best, and 400 jugera in the same district were also decreed
as a gift to Belligenes through whose instrumentality Moericus had
been induced to change sides. After Marcellus' departure from Sicily
a Carthaginian fleet landed a force of 8000 infantry and 3000 Numidian
horse. The cities of Murgentia and Ergetium revolted to them, and
their example was followed by Hybla and Macella and some other less
important places. Muttines and his Numidians were also roaming all
through the island and laying waste the fields of Rome's allies
with fire. To add to these troubles the Roman army bitterly resented
not being withdrawn from the province with their commander and also
not being allowed to winter in the towns. Consequently they were
very remiss in their military duties; in fact it was only the absence
of a leader that prevented them from breaking out into open mutiny.
In spite of these difficulties the praetor M. Cornelius succeeded
by remonstrances and reassurances in calming the temper of his men,
and then reduced all the revolted cities to submission. In pursuance
of the senate's orders he selected Murgentia, one of those cities,
for the settlement of Moericus and his Spaniards.
26.22
As both the consuls had Apulia for their province, and as there
was less danger from Hannibal and his Carthaginians, they received
instructions to ballot for Apulia and Macedonia. Macedonia fell
to Sulpicius, and he superseded Laevinus. Fulvius was recalled to
conduct the consular elections in Rome. The Veturian century of
juniors was the first to vote, and they declared for T. Manlius
Torquatus and T. Otacilius, the latter being at the time absent
from Rome. The voters began to press round Manlius to congratulate
him, regarding his election as a certainty, but he at once proceeded,
surrounded by a large crowd, to the consul's tribunal and begged
to be allowed to make a brief speech and also asked that the century
which had voted might be recalled. When all were on the tiptoe of
expectation to learn what he wanted, he began by excusing himself
on the score of his eyesight. "A man must have little sense of shame,"
he continued "whether he be pilot of a ship or commander of an army,
who asks that the lives and fortunes of others should be committed
to him when, in all he does, he has to depend upon other people's
eyes. If, therefore, you approve, order the Veturian century of
juniors to cast their vote again, and to remember, whilst they are
choosing their consuls, the war in Italy and the critical position
of the republic. Your ears can hardly yet have recovered from the
uproar and confusion caused by the enemy a few months ago, when
he brought the flames of war almost up to the very walls of Rome."
The century replied with a general shout that they had not changed
their minds, they should vote as before. Then Torquatus said, "I
shall not be able to tolerate your manners and conduct, nor will
you submit to my authority. Go back and vote again, and bear in
mind that the Carthaginians are carrying war in Italy, and that
their leader is Hannibal." Then the century, swayed by the speaker's
personal authority and by the murmurs of admiration which they heard
all around them, begged the consul to call up the Veturian century
of seniors, as they wished to consult their elders and be guided
by their advice in the choice of consuls. They were accordingly
called up and an interval was allowed for the two bodies to consult
privately in the ovile. The seniors maintained that the choice really
lay between three men, two of them already full of honours-Q. Fabius
and M. Marcellus-and, if they particularly wished a new man to be
appointed consul to act against the Carthaginians, M. Valerius Laevinus,
who had conducted operations against Philip both by sea and land
with conspicuous success. So they discussed the claims of these
three, and after the seniors had withdrawn the juniors proceeded
to vote. They gave their vote in favour of M. Marcellus Claudius,
resplendent with the glory of his conquest of Sicily, and, as the
second consul, M. Valerius. Neither of them had put in a personal
appearance. The other centuries all followed the leading century.
People nowadays may laugh at the admirers of antiquity. I for my
part do not believe it possible, even if there ever existed a commonwealth
of wise men such as philosophers dream of but have never really
known, that there could be an aristocracy more grave or more temperate
in their desire for power or a people with purer manners and a higher
moral tone. That a century of juniors should have been anxious to
consult their seniors as to whom they were to place in supreme authority
is a thing hardly credible in these days, when we see in what contempt
children hold the authority of their parents.
26.23
Then followed the election of praetors. The successful candidates
were P. Manlius Vulso, L. Manlius Acidinus, C. Laetorius and L.
Cincius Alimentus. When the elections were over news came of the
death of T. Otacilius in Sicily. He was the man whom the people
would have given to T. Manlius as his colleague in the consulship,
if the order of the proceedings had not been interrupted. The Games
of Apollo had been exhibited the previous year, and when the question
of their repetition the next year was moved by the praetor Calpurnius,
the senate passed a decree that they should be observed for all
time. Some portents were observed this year and duly reported. The
statue of victory which stood on the roof of the temple of Concord
was struck by lightning and thrown down on to the statues of Victory
which stood above the facade in front of the pediment, and here
it was caught and prevented from falling lower. At Anagnia and Fregellae
the walls and gates were reported to have been struck. In the forum
of Subertum streams of blood had flowed for a whole day. At Eretium
there was a shower of stones and at Reate a mule had produced offspring.
These portents were expiated by sacrifices of full-grown victims;
a day was appointed for special intercessions and the people were
ordered to join in solemn rites for nine days. Some members of the
national priesthood died this year, and others were appointed in
their stead. Manlius Aemilius Numida, one of the Keepers of the
Sacred Books, was succeeded by M. Aemilius Lepidus. C. Livius was
appointed pontiff in the room of M. Pomponius Matho, and M. Servilius,
augur, in the place of Spurius Carvilius Maximus. The death of the
pontiff T. Otacilius Crassus did not occur before the close of the
year, so no one was appointed in his place. C. Claudius, one of
the Flamens of Jupiter, was guilty of irregularity in laying the
selected parts of the victim on the altar and consequently resigned
his office.
26.24
M. Valerius Laevinus had been holding private interviews with some
of the leading Aetolians with the view of ascertaining their political
leanings. It was arranged that a meeting of their national council
should be convened to meet him, and thither he proceeded with some
fast-sailing vessels. He commenced his address to the assembly by
alluding to the captures of Syracuse and Capua as instances of the
success which had attended the arms of Rome in Sicily and Italy,
and then proceeded: "It is the practice of the Romans, a practice
handed down from their ancestors, to cultivate the friendship of
other nations; some of them they have received into citizenship
on the same footing as themselves; others they have allowed to remain
under such favourable conditions that they preferred alliance to
full citizenship. You, Aetolians, will be held in all the greater
honour because you will have been the first of all the oversea nations
to establish friendly relations with us. Philip and the Macedonians
you find to be troublesome neighbours; I have already dealt a fatal
blow to their ambitions and aggressiveness, and I shall reduce them
to such a pass that they will not only evacuate those cities which
they have wrested from you, but will have enough to do to defend
Macedonia itself. The Acarnanians, too, whose secession from your
league you feel so keenly, I shall bring back to the old terms by
which your rights and suzerainty over them were guaranteed." These
assertions and promises of the Roman commander were supported by
Scopas, the chief magistrate of Aetolia at the time, and by Dorimachus,
a leading man amongst them, both of whom from their official position
spoke with authority. They were less reserved, and adopted a more
confident tone as they extolled the power and greatness of Rome.
What weighed most, however, with the Assembly was the hope of becoming
masters of Acarnania.
The terms on which they were to become the friends and allies of
Rome were reduced to writing and an additional clause was inserted
that if it was their will and pleasure the Eleans and Lacedaemonians
as well as Attalus, Pleuratus and Scerdilaedus might be included
in the treaty. Attalus was king of Pergamum in Asia Minor; Pleuratus,
king of the Thracians; Scerdilaedus, king of the Illyrians. The
Aetolians were at once to commence war with Philip on land, and
the Roman general would assist them with not less than twenty-five
quinqueremes. The territories, buildings and walls of all the cities
as far as Corcyra were to become the property of the Aetolians,
all the other booty was to go to the Romans, who were also to be
responsible for Acarnania passing under the dominion of the Aetolians.
Should the Aetolians make peace with Philip, one of the conditions
was to be that he would abstain from hostilities against Rome and
her allies and dependencies. Similarly, if the Romans made a treaty
with him it was to be a provision that he should not be allowed
to make war upon the Aetolians and their allies. These were the
agreed conditions, and after a lapse of two years, copies of the
treaty were deposited by the Aetolians at Olympia, and by the Romans
in the Capitol, in order that the sacred memorials round them might
be a perpetual witness to their obligation. The reason for this
delay was that the Aetolian envoys had been detained for a considerable
time in Rome. No time, however, was lost in commencing hostilities,
and Laevinus attacked Zacynthus. This is a small island adjacent
to Aetolia, and it contains one city of the same name as the island;
this city, with the exception of its citadel, Laevinus captured.
He also took two cities belonging to the Acarnanians-Oeniadae and
Nasos-and handed them over to the Aetolians. After this he withdrew
to Corcyra, feeling satisfied that Philip had enough on his hands
with the war on his frontiers to prevent him from thinking about
Italy and the Carthaginians and his compact with Hannibal.
26.25
Philip was wintering in Pella when the news of the defection of
the Aetolians reached him. He had intended to march into Greece
at the beginning of the spring, and with the view of keeping the
Illyrians and the cities adjacent to his western frontier quiet
he made a sudden invasion into the territories of Oricum and Apollonia.
The men of Apollonia came out to give battle, but he drove them
back in great panic to their walls. After devastating the neighbouring
district of Illyria, he turned swiftly into Pelagonia and captured
Sintia, a city of the Dardani, which gave them easy access into
Macedonia. After these rapid incursions he turned his attention
to the war which the Aetolians, in conjunction with the Romans,
were commencing against him. Marching through Pelagonia, Lyncus
and Bottiaea he descended into Thessaly, whose population he hoped
to rouse to joint action with him against the Aetolians. Leaving
Perseus with a force of 4000 men to hold the pass into Thessaly
against them he returned to Macedonia, before engaging in the more
serious contest, and from there marched into Thrace to attack the
Maedi. This tribe were in the habit of making incursions into Macedonia
whenever they found the king occupied with some distant war and
his kingdom unprotected. To break their aggressiveness he devastated
their country, and attacked Iamphoryna, their chief city and stronghold.
When Scopas heard that the king had gone into Thessaly, and was
engaged in hostilities there, he called up all the fighting men
of Aetolia and prepared to invade Acarnania. The Acarnanians were
inferior to their enemy in strength; they were also aware that Oeniadae
and Nasos were lost, and above all, that the arms of Rome were turned
against them. Under these circumstances they entered upon the struggle
more in a spirit of rage and despair than with prudence and method.
Their wives and children and all men over sixty years of age were
sent into the adjoining country of Epirus. All who were between
fifteen and sixty bound themselves by oath not to return home unless
they were victorious, and if any one left the field, defeated, no
man should receive him into any city or house or admit him to his
table or his hearth. They drew up a form of words, invoking a terrible
curse upon any of their countrymen who should prove recreants, and
a most solemn appeal to their hosts, the Epirotes, to respect their
oath. They also begged them to bury those of their countrymen who
fell in battle in one common grave and place over it this inscription:
"Here lie the Acarnanians who met their death whilst fighting for
their country against the violence and injustice of the Aetolians."
In this determined and desperate mood, they fixed their camp on
the extreme limit of their borders and awaited the enemy. Messengers
were despatched to Philip to announce their critical situation,
and in spite of his recapture of Iamphoryna and other successes
in Thrace he was compelled to abandon his northern campaign and
go to their assistance. Rumours of the oath which the Acarnanians
had taken arrested the advance of the Aetolians; the news of Philip's
approach compelled them to withdraw into the interior of their country.
Philip had made a forced march to prevent the Acarnanians from being
crushed, but he did not advance beyond Dium, and on learning that
the Aetolians had retired he returned to Pella.
26.26
At the beginning of spring Laevinus set sail from Corcyra and after
rounding the promontory of Leucata reached Naupactus. He announced
that he was going on to attack Anticyra, so that Scopas and the
Aetolians might be ready for him there. Anticyra is situated in
Locris, on the left hand as you enter the Corinthian Gulf, and is
only a short distance either by sea or land from Naupactus. In three
days the attack began in both directions; the naval attack was the
heavier one because the ships were furnished with artillery and
engines of every kind, and it was the Romans who were delivering
the attack on this side. In a few days the place surrendered and
was made over to the Aetolians; the booty in accordance with the
treaty became the property of the Romans. During the siege a despatch
was handed to Laevinus informing him that he had been made consul,
and that P. Sulpicius was coming to succeed him. Whilst he was there
he was overtaken by a tedious illness, and consequently arrived
in Rome much later than was expected. M. Marcellus entered upon
his consulship on March 15, and in order to comply with traditional
usage summoned a meeting of the senate on the same day. The meeting
was a purely formal one; he announced that in his colleague's absence
he should not submit any proposals either in respect of the policy
of the State or the assignment of provinces. "I am quite aware,"
he told the senators, "that there are a large body of Sicilians
quartered in the country houses of my detractors round the City.
I have no intention of preventing them from publishing here in Rome
the charges which have been got up by my enemies; on the contrary,
I was prepared to give them an immediate opportunity of appearing
before the senate had they not pretended to be afraid of speaking
about a consul in his colleague's absence. When, however, my colleague
has come I shall not allow any business to be discussed before the
Sicilians have been brought into the senate house. M. Cornelius
has issued what is practically a formal summons throughout the island
in order that as many as possible might come to Rome to lay their
complaints against me. He has filled the City with letters containing
false information about a state of war existing in Sicily, solely
that he may tarnish my reputation." The consul's speech won for
him the reputation of being a man of moderation and self-control.
The senate adjourned, and it seemed as though there would be a total
suspension of business pending the other consul's arrival. As usual,
idleness led to discontent and grumbling. The plebs were loud in
their complaints about the way the war dragged on, the devastation
of the land round the City wherever Hannibal and his army moved,
the exhaustion of Italy by the constant levies, the almost annual
destruction of their armies. And now the new consuls were both of
them fond of war, far too enterprising and ambitious, quite capable,
even in a time of peace and quiet, of getting up a war, and now
that war was actually going on all the less likely to allow the
citizens any respite or breathing space.
26.27
All this talk was suddenly interrupted by a fire which broke out
in the night in several places round the Forum on the eve of the
Quinquatrus. Seven shops which were afterwards replaced by five
were burning at the same time, as well as the offices where the
New Banks now stand. Soon after, private buildings-the Basilicae
did not yet exist-the Lautumiae, the Fish Market and the Hall of
Vesta were alight. It was with the utmost difficulty that the Temple
of Vesta was saved, mainly through the exertions of thirteen slaves,
who were afterwards manumitted at the public cost. The fire raged
all through the next day and there was not the smallest doubt that
it was the work of incendiaries, for fires started simultaneously
in several different places. The senate accordingly authorised the
consul to give public notice that whoever disclosed the names of
those through whose agency the conflagration had been started should,
if he were a freeman, receive a reward, if a slave, his liberty.
Tempted by the offer of a reward, a slave belonging to the Capuan
family of the Calavii, called Manus, gave information to the effect
that his masters, together with five young Capuan nobles, whose
fathers had been beheaded by Q. Fulvius, had caused the fire and
were prepared to commit every description of crime if they were
not arrested. They and their slaves were at once apprehended. At
first they endeavoured to throw suspicion upon the informer and
his statement. It was asserted that after being beaten by his master,
the day before he gave information, he had run away and had made
out of an occurrence which was really accidental the foundation
of a false charge. When, however, the accused and accuser were brought
face to face and the slaves were examined under torture, they all
confessed. The masters as well as the slaves who had been their
accessories were all executed. The informer was rewarded with his
liberty and 20,000 ases.
When Laevinus was passing Capua on his way to Rome he was surrounded
by a crowd of the inhabitants who implored him with tears to allow
them to go to Rome and try if they could not awaken the compassion
of the senate and persuade them not to allow Q. Flaccus to ruin
them utterly and efface their name. Flaccus declared that he had
no personal feeling against the Capuans, it was as public enemies
that he regarded them, and should continue to do so as long as he
knew that they maintained their present attitude towards Rome. He
had shut them up, he said, within their walls, because if they got
out anywhere they would prowl about the country like wild beasts,
and mangle and murder whatever came in their way. Some had deserted
to Hannibal, others had gone off to burn down Rome. The consul would
see in the half-burnt Forum the result of their crime. They had
tried to destroy the temple of Vesta, with its perpetual fire, and
the image which was concealed in the sacred shrine-that image which
Fate had decreed to be the pledge and guarantee of Roman dominion.
He considered that it would be anything but safe to give the Capuans
a chance of entering the City. After hearing this Laevinus made
the Capuans take an oath to Flaccus that they would return within
five days after receiving the reply of the senate. Then he ordered
them to follow him to Rome. Surrounded by this crowd and by a number
of Sicilians who had also met him, he entered the City. It seemed
just as though he were bringing in a body of accusers against the
two commanders who had distinguished themselves by the destruction
of two famous cities and who would now have to defend themselves
against those they had vanquished.
26.28
The first questions, however, which the two consuls brought before
the senate were those relating to foreign policy and the allocation
of the various commands. Laevinus made his report on the situation
in Macedonia and Greece, and the unrest amongst the Aetolians, the
Acarnanians and the Locrians. He also gave details as to his own
military and naval movements, and stated that he had driven Philip,
who was meditating an attack on the Aetolians, back into the interior
of his kingdom. The legion could now be safely withdrawn, as the
fleet was sufficient to protect Italy from any attempt on the part
of the king. After this statement about himself and the province
of which he had had charge, he and his colleague raised the question
of the various commands. The senate made the following dispositions.
One consul was to operate in Italy against Hannibal; the other was
to succeed T. Otacilius in command of the fleet and also to administer
Sicily with L. Cincius as praetor. They were to take over the armies
in Etruria and Gaul, each of which comprised two legions. The two
City legions which the consul Sulpicius had commanded the previous
year were sent to Gaul, and the consul who was to act in Italy was
to appoint to the command in Gaul. C. Calpurnius had his office
of propraetor extended for a year, and was sent into Etruria, Q.
Fulvius also received a year's extension of his command at Capua.
The composite force of citizens and allies was reduced, one strong
legion being formed out of the two; this consisted of 5000 infantry
and 300 cavalry, those who had served longest being sent home. The
army of the allies was reduced to 7000 infantry and 300 cavalry,
the same rule being observed as to the release of the veterans who
had seen the longest service. In the case of the retiring consul,
Cn. Fulvius, no change was made; he retained his army and his province,
Apulia, for another year. His late colleague, P. Sulpicius, received
orders to disband his entire army with the exception of the naval
force. Similarly the army which M. Cornelius had commanded was to
be sent home from Sicily. The men of Cannae, who practically represented
two legions, were still to remain in the island, under the command
of the praetor L. Cincius. L. Cornelius had commanded the same number
of legions the previous year in Sardinia, and these were now transferred
to the praetor P. Manlius Vulso. The consuls received instructions
to see that in raising the City legions, none were enrolled who
had been in the army of M. Valerius, or in that of Q. Fulvius. So
the total number of Roman legions in active service that year was
not to exceed one-and-twenty.
26.29
When the senate had finished making the appointments, the consuls
were ordered to ballot for their commands. Sicily and the fleet
fell to Marcellus, Italy and the campaign against Hannibal to Laevinus.
This result utterly appalled the Sicilians, to whom it seemed as
though all the horrors of the capture of Syracuse were to be repeated.
They were standing in full view of the consuls, waiting anxiously
for the result of the balloting, and when they saw how it was decided,
they broke out into loud laments and cries of distress, which drew
the eyes of all upon them for the moment, and became the subject
of much comment afterwards. Clothing themselves in mourning garb
they visited the houses of the senators and assured each of them
in turn that if Marcellus went back to Sicily with the power and
authority of a consul they would every one of them abandon his city
and quit the island for ever. He had, they said, before shown himself
vindictive and implacable towards them; what would he do now, furious
as he was at the Sicilians who had come to Rome to complain of him?
It would be better for the island to be buried beneath the fires
of Aetna or plunged in the depths of the sea than to be given up
to such an enemy to wreak his rage and vengeance on it. These remonstrances
of the Sicilians were made to individual nobles in their own homes,
and gave rise to lively discussions, in which sympathy with the
sufferers and hostile sentiments towards Marcellus were freely expressed.
At last they reached the senate. The consuls were requested to consult
that body as to the advisability of a rearrangement of the provinces.
In addressing the House Marcellus said that had the Sicilians been
already admitted to an audience he would have taken a different
line, but as matters stood, he did not wish it to be open to any
one to say that they were afraid to lay their complaints against
the man in whose power they would shortly be placed. If, therefore,
it made no difference to his colleague he was prepared to exchange
provinces with him. He begged the senate not to make any order,
for since it would have been unfair to him for his colleague to
have chosen his province without recourse to the ballot, how much
more unfair and even humiliating to him would it be now to have
the province which had fallen to him formally transferred to his
colleague! After indicating their wish, without embodying it in
a decree, the senate adjourned, and the consuls themselves arranged
to exchange provinces. Marcellus was being hurried on by his destiny
to meet Hannibal, in order that, as he was the first Roman general
to win the distinction of a successful action with him after so
many disastrous ones, so he would be the last to contribute to the
Carthaginian's reputation by his own fall, and that just at the
time when the war was going most favourably for the Romans.
26.30
When the exchange of provinces had been decided, the Sicilians
were introduced into the senate. After expatiating at some length
upon the unbroken loyalty of Hiero to Rome, and claiming the credit
of it for the people rather than for the king, they proceeded: "There
were many reasons for the hatred we felt towards Hieronymus and
afterwards towards Hippocrates and Epicydes, but the principal one
was their abandoning Rome for Hannibal. It was this that led some
of the foremost of our younger men to assassinate Hieronymus close
to the senate-house, and also induced some seventy who belonged
to our noblest houses to form a plot for the destruction of Epicydes
and Hippocrates. As Marcellus failed to support them by bringing
up his army to Syracuse at the time he promised, the plot was disclosed
by an informer, and they were all put to death by the tyrants. Marcellus
was really responsible for the tyranny, owing to his ruthless sacking
of Leontium. From that time the Syracusan leaders never ceased to
go over to Marcellus and undertake to deliver up the city to him
whenever he wished. He would rather have taken it by storm, but
when all his attempts by sea and land failed, and he saw that the
thing was impossible, he chose as agents of the surrender an artisan
called Sosis and the Spaniard Moericus, rather than let the leaders
of the city, who had so often offered in vain to do so, undertake
the task. No doubt he considered that he would thus have more justification
for plundering and massacring the friends of Rome. Even if the revolt
to Hannibal had been the act of senate and people and not simply
of Hieronymus; if it had been the government of Syracuse who closed
the gates against Marcellus, and not the tyrants Hippocrates and
Epicydes who had ousted the government; if we had warred against
Rome in the spirit and temper of the Carthaginians, what greater
severity could Marcellus have shown towards us than that which he
actually practiced, unless he had blotted Syracuse out from the
face of the earth? At all events, nothing has been left to us beyond
our walls and our houses stripped of everything, and the defaced
and despoiled temples of our gods, from which even the gods themselves
and their votive offerings have been carried off. Many have been
deprived of their land, so that they have not even the bare soil
on which to support themselves, and all who belong to them, with
the remains of their wrecked fortunes. We beg and entreat you, senators,
if you cannot order all that we have lost to be restored to us,
at least to insist upon the restitution of what can be found and
identified." After they had stated their grievances, Laevinus ordered
them to withdraw, that their position might be discussed. "Let them
stop," exclaimed Marcellus, "that I may make my reply in their presence,
since we who conduct war on your behalf, senators, must do so on
condition of those whom we have vanquished coming forward as our
accusers. Two cities have been taken this year: let Capua call Fabius
to account, and Syracuse, Marcellus."
26.31
When they had been brought back into the senate-house, Marcellus
made the following speech: "I have not so far forgotten, senators,
the majesty of Rome or the dignity of my office as to stoop to defend
myself, as consul, against the charges of these Greeks, if they
concerned me alone. The question is not so much what I have done
as what they ought to have suffered. Had they not been enemies it
is a matter of indifference whether I maltreated Syracuse now or
in Hiero's lifetime. But if they have proved false to us, opened
their gates to the enemy, threatened our envoys with drawn swords,
shut their city and walls against us and called in a Carthaginian
army to protect them against us, who is there who can feel any indignation
at their having suffered hostile violence after having practiced
it? I declined the offers of their leaders to deliver up the city,
and looked upon Sosis and the Spaniard Moericus as much more suitable
persons to be trusted in a matter of such importance. As you make
their humble sta |